If you're searching for top-notch seafood in Baldwinsville, NY, look no further than Atlantic Seafood Co. Nestled at 69 E Genesee St, this gem has become a beloved staple in the community, known for its fresh, homemade dishes that keep customers coming back for more. With a focus on quality and freshness, the restaurant prides itself on serving seafood straight from the fridge to the fryer, offering an unmatched culinary experience that reflects the true essence of coastal cuisine.

From their perfectly fried fish and succulent scallops to their tender shrimp and hearty chicken, Atlantic Seafood Co delivers large portions that leave patrons satisfied. The menu also features delightful sandwiches, clam chowder, and even a selection of homemade sides, creating a profound comfort food experience that resonates with diners of all ages.

The praise from customers speaks volumes. Jeremy Louis highlights the cleanliness of the establishment and the attentive service, noting that nothing is frozen—everything is prepared fresh in front of them. Shantea Watson echoes these sentiments, calling it a must-stop destination every time she drives by. With over forty years of service, as shared by long-time visitor Dawn Davis, the restaurant's longstanding reputation for consistent quality was clearly built on years of dedication to delicious, homemade seafood.

Janice Brown's rave about the haddock, whether fried or baked, showcases the chef’s ability to highlight each dish's natural flavors, further enhanced by a selection of delectable sides like macaroni salad and rice pudding. Joseph Woods appreciates the friendly atmosphere, which complements the dining experience perfectly. With a focus primarily on take-out, Atlantic Seafood Co also offers ample parking, making it convenient for those on the go.

In essence, Atlantic Seafood Co is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary haven where freshness and flavor take center stage. The vibrant community atmosphere, combined with quality ingredients and prepared with care, makes it a must-visit for seafood lovers and comfort food enthusiasts alike. Whether you're stopping by for a quick meal or picking up dinner for the family, you're guaranteed a satisfying experience that keeps you coming back.